EADT PUBLISHED: 07:02 15 December 2019
Suffolk Coastal MP Therese Coffey has co-signed a letter calling for an offshore ring main to be investigated. Mid Norfolk MP George Freeman wrote the letter Picture: Keiron Tovell. Read Letter
While renewable energy is widely supported, there are concerns the associated onshore infrastructure, including substations, could risk "industrialising" the region's most treasured landscapes.
The concerns have been heightened by a recent bid to build a substation on a 30 acre site in Friston to serve ScottishPower Renewables' (SPR) East Anglia Two and One North wind farms.
And with the region expected to see further growth in offshore wind, communities are urging Government and National Grid to find less disruptive solutions.
A group of East Anglian MPs wrote to the Secretary of State for BEIS Andrea Leadsom in October to press the case for an 'offshore ring main' (ORM).
Led by George Freeman, whose Mid Norfolk constituency is facing proposals for a large substation to serve offshore wind, the letter highlighted a "serious strategic policy challenges raised by the lack of an overall strategy for the connection of offshore wind infrastructure."
The letter, which was co-signed by Suffolk Coastal MP Therese Coffey called for a review into the potential ORM which it said could avoid the need for "multiple onshore cable corridors and substations across the Norfolk and Suffolk coasts".
An ORM would see several wind farms connect to the same marine cable, requiring only two land connections - and two substations.
The scheme has been previously dismissed. A 2015 report by National Grid and offshore energy companies found "it would be economic and efficient."
But recently National Grid said it was exploring the possibility. Energy Minister Claire Perry also told Suffolk councils it was an "interesting idea" she would ask her officials to investigate further.
Simon Gray, chief executive of the East of England Energy Group, warned of the cost implications for the consumer.
SPR said it was "generally supportive" of a more strategically planned offshore grid network but added the ORM would require "fundamental changes" to the electricity market and planning regulations.
Michael Mahony, of Substation Action Save East Suffolk said the calls were a "small step in the right direction" but called for a "moratorium" on live projects.
Campaigners encouraged by delayed decision
Hopes wind farm decisions could be paused until a review is held into their cumulative impacts have been heightened by a victory for Norfolk campaigners.
The government recently delayed its decision on whether to allow the huge Norfolk Vanguard wind farm, asking developers Vattenfall to address concerns raised on issues ranging from traffic to the environment.
Campaign groups had been particularly concerned by the cable route and substation that would have been built onshore at Necton. Together with Mid Norfolk MP George Freeman, they had been pushing for a review of the onshore connections, arguing an offshore ring main should be sought, to minimise disruption.
Suffolk campaigners welcomed the news and hope it may have wider implications for wind farm applications in the region.
Fiona Gilmore of Suffolk Energy Action Solutions said it was "really encouraging news". Given the many questions raised locally about the cumulative impact of these projects, she said the Government should call a "moratorium" until a "holistic strategy " for offshore wind could be agreed.
"Green energy, the environment and economic and social well- being have to be considered within an integrated programme of planning, not in isolation of each other," she added.
A recent study says that often wind, solar and hydro schemes have been built inareas of environmental significance and pose a threat to key natural habitats. The authors of the report say that greater care must be taken when planning and permitting renewable facilities. "If we let these developments go ahead, the biodiversity will be gone long before climate change starts affecting it.....we are not saying that renewables are bad, we just need to put them in the right places."
European grid operators want to combine 10-gigawatt offshore turbine clusters, interconnectors and hydrogen. It no longer looks like a pipe dream.